Activists picket UN panel’s Sandton meeting

Organisation: Position: Deadline Date: Location:

Dozens of activists and patients last week picketed outside the Johannesburg meeting of a United Nations (UN) high level panel on access to medicines. Health-e News reports that activists have demanded governments fund more drug research and development.

Donning t-shirts emblazoned with the slogan, “No more delays, fix the patent laws in 2016,” about 60 activists gathered outside the Sandton Holiday Inn where they delivered a four-page letter of demands to members of the UN panel. The panel is currently reviewing how the needs of drug innovators can be balanced against patients’ need for affordable treatment. Globally, pharmaceutical companies continue to argue that the need to recoup research and development costs continue to drive high drug prices however activists say this is not always the case.

Among protesters’ demands was that governments fund the research and development of new medicines. The Treatment Action Campaign (TAC) has advocated for this previously especially in regards to developing new tuberculosis medicines.

In South Africa, activists have also blamed a lack of rigorous patent examination for allowing companies to gain unnecessary patents. Improved patent examination is just one of the features that organisations like TAC and the South African Non-Communicable Disease (NCD) Alliance will be hoping to see in the Department of Trade and Industry’s (DTI) new intellectual property policy. The DTI is expected to release a second draft of a proposed policy soon for public comment.

The report says among those who picketed were two women fighting to live and another, farther off, fighting to die with a purpose. Tobeka Daki was diagnosed with HER2-positive breast cancer in 2013. She joined more than 6,000 women who are diagnosed with cancer annually in South Africa. About a quarter of these women will develop the aggressive HER2-positive breast cancer, which is caused by a genetic mutation that produces an excess of the cancer-promoting protein, the human epidermal growth factor receptor 2 (HER2).

Daki’s medical aid refused to pay for the prescribed treatment Herceptin, which is a drug formulated to treat HER2 cancer, due to the drug’s high cost. A 12-month course of Herceptin costs about R500, 000 in the private sector. Pharmaceutical company Roche, which holds a patent on Herceptin until 2033, offers the drug at a discounted rate of R200, 000 per year per patient to the public sector. Daki did not receive Herceptin and in December was told that the cancer had spread to her spine.

“I strongly believe that none of this (further spread of the cancer) would have happened if I got this treatment,” Daki says. “If I get this treatment, I can live longer and see my two sons grow up.”

When Eastern Cape lawyer and HER2 cancer patient Babalwa Malgas was also denied treatment by her medical due to high drug costs, she did what any good lawyer would do: She started doing her own research. “When I got to the public health system, I discovered that they don’t offer Herceptin,” she is quoted in the report as saying. “In my own research, I discovered that it’s only Kimberly Hospital that provides its patients with Herceptin.”

“It also means that we don’t have equal access to health in the Eastern Cape,” said Malgas, who is now in remission but most go for regular screenings to make sure the cancer has not returned. “I had to struggle…with the legal cost of dealing with my medical aid first and the cost of trying to save my life.”

The report says according to Medicins Sans Frontières researcher Catherine Tomlinson, Roche’s South African patents on Herceptin in South Africa expire at least 10 years later than its US and UK patents. And proposed amendments to South Africa’s patent laws could help bring patents here more in line with those given out internationally and put drugs in the hands of patients like Daki and Malgas.

For Victoria Pinkney-Atkinson, these changes will come too late. Pinkney-Atkinson was born with the skin condition psoriasis. She would have been able to avoid the condition’s progression into debilitating arthritis if she had been able to afford proper treatment decades ago. “(The drugs) cost so much that as a single parent there was not way I was going to bankrupt my family to get the drugs,” said Pinkney-Atkinson, who now works for South Africa’s NCD Alliance.

Her inability to access the more expensive medication she needed has also meant that cheaper alternatives have wracked her immune system, leaving it vulnerable to a range of illnesses over the years. It also means that she is too weak to take the medication that could help manage her chronic pain.

Now in her 60s, Pinkney-Atkinson knows her condition will only get worse. “I’ve had so many near death experiences and I’ve lived in pain and agony for the last 30 years,” she is quoted in the report as saying. “I’m very calm about dying.”
Pinkney-Atkinson described how she came to make peace with the finality of her diagnosis. “I realise that now I have to use the rest of my life to make things different,” she said. “That’s how I made peace with it. I thought, “I survived for a reason,'” she said.


“This (drug prices) is not just a developing world issue. It affects patients in the UK and the US too, be it access to cancer drugs or medicines for hepatitis B,” Business Day quotes TAC head of policy Marcus Low as saying. “One of the key things this panel can do is break the passive acceptance that drugs are not available because they are too expensive.”

The panel has been charged by UN secretary-general Ban Ki-moon with assessing submissions and making recommendations on ways to realign the right to health with trade rules. Its 16 members include health director-general Precious Matsoso, GlaxoSmithKline CEO Andrew Witty and Botswana’s former president Festus Mogae.

The panel met last week in London and for two days this week in Johannesburg, where it heard testimony from organisations and patients. It will report to the UN secretary-general in June.

The report says TAC is among the local activists that signed a declaration from civil society groups from around the world submitted to the panel. Local organisations that signed the declaration included Section 27, the South African Federation for Mental Health and leading cancer lobby groups.

Among the measures recommended by the activists is the delinking of research and development costs from the price of medical technologies, such as vaccines and medicines, the report says. “Governments could start this right away,” said Low.

The TAC hoped the panel would recommend a global research and development treaty that would see governments commit money towards research into neglected fields, such as tuberculosis (TB),” Low said. “TB is the world’s top infectious killer, responsible for 1.5-million deaths in 2014, yet less than $100m was invested in research and development for TB last year,” he said. Most funding for tuberculosis research was provided by the US National Institutes for Health, yet 40% of the global burden resided within Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa, he added.

A representative of GlaxoSmithKline said most of the medicines on the World Health Organisation’s essential drugs list were no longer under patent and there were cheap generics.

Health-e News material
Full Business Day report

Receive Medical Brief's free weekly e-newsletter

Related Posts

Thank you for subscribing to MedicalBrief

MedicalBrief is Africa’s premier medical news and research weekly newsletter. MedicalBrief is published every Thursday and delivered free of charge by email to over 33 000 health professionals.

Please consider completing the form below. The information you supply is optional and will only be used to compile a demographic profile of our subscribers. Your personal details will never be shared with a third party.

Thank you for taking the time to complete the form.