A US research team has developed an algorithm that by analysing stool samples quickly and inexpensively identifies liver fibrosis and cirrhosis over 90% of the time in human patients.
Chronic liver disease represents a major global public health problem affecting an estimated 844m people, according to the World Health Organisation. It is among the top causes of mortality in Australia, the UK and the US. At the same time, it is both difficult to manage and there is no US Food Drug Administration (FDA)-approved anti-fibrotic liver therapy. The microbiome – a complex collection of microbes that inhabit the gut – may be an unexpected indictor of health. Now, a collaborative team of Salk Institute and University of California – San Diego scientists have created a novel microbiome-based diagnostic tool that, with the accuracy of the best physicians, quickly and inexpensively identifies liver fibrosis and cirrhosis over 90% of the time in human patients.
The non-invasive method relies on an algorithm to analyse patient stool samples – which contains traces of what lives in the gut – and could lead to improved patient care and treatment outcomes for liver disease.
"The microbiome is a dynamic living sensor of small changes in health and disease in the body, and as such, it provides an accurate readout of body health," says Salk Professor Ronald Evans, co-corresponding author and holder of the March of Dimes chair. "Because this diagnostic is fast and low-cost, it could be something that becomes widely used, especially in the many areas that lack specialty clinics and physicians. Simply said, it could be a real game changer, with world-wide implications."
Non-alcoholic fatty liver disease (NAFLD) is the leading cause of chronic liver disease globally and can progress to liver fibrosis and cirrhosis and potentially cancer, as the liver starts to experience scarring and cell death. But diagnostic tools for liver fibrosis and cirrhosis are lacking. Biopsies are invasive and can miss injured regions of the liver, and MRIs are expensive and are often not available in rural areas. To address these challenges, the research team explored the microbiome as a way to meet the urgent need for a new test to identify patients at risk.
"We sought to develop a universal, non-invasive test for liver fibrosis and cirrhosis based on a 'microbiome signature' of the disease," says Michael Downes, a Salk senior staff scientist and co-author of the study.
In collaboration with scientists from the UC San Diego Department of Medicine, the team optimised a computational method called machine learning to uncover a complex disease signature based on 19 bacterial species present in the stool samples of a patient group. The signature is made up of the different quantities of bacteria, creating a universal fingerprint for identifying liver fibrosis and cirrhosis. The study included 163 clinical samples from both healthy as well as sick family members to identify variables that were indicative of liver disease.
Using data from microbiome genetic profiling and from metabolites from the stool samples, the researchers discovered a microbiome signature that was associated with a cirrhosis diagnosis with 94% accuracy. The microbiome signature could also determine the stage of liver fibrosis, which could allow doctors to grade patients based on their stage of the disease and improve treatment strategies.
"These findings demonstrate that it is possible to use machine learning to identify a universal signature that can be used for accurate diagnosis of a disease, such as liver cirrhosis," says Tae Gyu Oh, first author of the paper and a post-doctoral researcher in the Evans lab. "The patterns we found reflect the complexity of the microbiome and how gut health likely affects disease."
The researchers then applied their microbiome signature to two independent populations of patients from China and Italy. The team's signature could accurately identify cirrhosis in over 90% of patients, which validates the power and accuracy of the algorithm across different genetics and diets.
"It is remarkable that a gut microbiome signature derived from patients residing in Southern California for cirrhosis was able to predict cirrhosis in two independent cohorts residing in China and Italy. It speaks to the new discoveries that are yet to be realized in the role of the gut microbiome to diagnose and risk-stratify liver disease," says Rohit Loomba, co-corresponding author and director of the NAFLD Research Centre at the UC San Diego School of Medicine. "I think the power of using the microbiome as a diagnostic tool is only starting to be realised."
In the future, the scientists will examine the causal link between the microbiome and liver disease by testing whether restoring parts of the microbiome leads to regression of the disease or removing certain bacteria makes it worse. The team also hopes this approach can be used to characterize additional diseases, such as inflammatory bowel disease, colon cancer, Alzheimer's and other diseases shown to be likely affected by a dysregulated microbiome.
Dysregulation of the gut microbiome has been implicated in the progression of non-alcoholic fatty liver disease (NAFLD) to advanced fibrosis and cirrhosis. To determine the diagnostic capacity of this association, we compared stool microbiomes across 163 well-characterized participants encompassing non-NAFLD controls, NAFLD-cirrhosis patients, and their first-degree relatives. Interrogation of shotgun metagenomic and untargeted metabolomic profiles by using the random forest machine learning algorithm and differential abundance analysis identified discrete metagenomic and metabolomic signatures that were similarly effective in detecting cirrhosis (diagnostic accuracy 0.91, area under curve [AUC]). Combining the metagenomic signature with age and serum albumin levels accurately distinguished cirrhosis in etiologically and genetically distinct cohorts from geographically separated regions. Additional inclusion of serum aspartate aminotransferase levels, which are increased in cirrhosis patients, enabled discrimination of cirrhosis from earlier stages of fibrosis. These findings demonstrate that a core set of gut microbiome species might offer universal utility as a non-invasive diagnostic test for cirrhosis.
Tae Gyu Oh, Susy M Kim, Cyrielle Caussy, Ting Fu, Jian Guo, Shirin Bassirian, Seema Singh, Egbert V Madamba, Ricki Bettencourt, Lisa Richards, Manuela Raffatellu, Pieter C Dorrestein, Ruth T Yu, Annette R Atkins, Tao Huan, David A Brenner, Claude B Sirlin, Rob Knight, Michael Downes, Ronald M Evans, Rohit Loomba
Salk Institute material
Cell Metabolsim abstract