Monday, 23 May, 2022
HomeFrom the FrontlinesCharlotte Maxeke debacle places ‘enormous load’ on Helen Joseph Hospital

Charlotte Maxeke debacle places ‘enormous load’ on Helen Joseph Hospital

Helen Joseph Hospital patients are being examined and treated in the corridors, because of a bed shortage, while the hospital’s trauma load has more than doubled and its psychiatric patient numbers more than quadrupled since Charlotte Maxeke Johannesburg Academic Hospital (CMJAH) closed after fire damage in April last year.

Scores of frustrated and over-worked doctors and nurses picketed outside Helen Joseph Hospital’s emergency department on Monday (14 March), demanding that government reopen CMJAH. They called on Gauteng Health to not only announce but to also honour a date for the full reopening of the hospital.

Dr Pat Saffy, head of Helen Joseph Hospital’s emergency department, told City Press that the enormous patient load had forced psychiatric patients to occupy the passages of the facility.

“They’re living in the corridors. They’ve moved out the medical patients, so the psychiatric patients are living there too. There’s only one toilet and only one shower. There’s barely any water for them,” she said.

The CMJAH’s emergency and psychiatric departments have yet to reopen, while all other departments are running on a smaller scale since the blaze on 16 April 2021. The reopening of the hospital’s emergency department has repeatedly been delayed.

Saffy said Helen Josephs’ frontline workers are burnt out and frustrated, and bear the brunt of patients’ aggression and dissatisfaction. Increasingly angry patients have assaulted doctors, lowering their morale.

“Doctors and the nurses are at risk of assault. We’ve had a large number of attacks in the past few months. When you’re upset, you don’t work well. You go home and don’t want to come to work the next day, so you take sick leave,” she told City Press.

“If they don’t come to work, the more likely it is that patients will die. There’s no way doctors can cope with the workload.”

In the past 11 months, Helen Joseph’s emergency department has consistently scored within the dangerously overcrowded range, using the national emergency department overcrowding criteria.

“The expectation that an already overstretched 600-bed hospital will take on a load of a 1,000-bed hospital without an adequate contingency plan is unrealistic," she said.

Helen Joseph Hospital’s head of infectious diseases Jeremy Nel was among the protesters. He read out their memorandum of demands to Gauteng health officials.

These included:

  • Equitable distribution of staff from the CMJAH for the provision of services in the emergency trauma and psychiatric departments, as the patient load was from their drainage area;
  • Provision of resources and budget to compensate for patients who would have been treated at the CMJAH;
  • The assistance of other facilities within the CMJAH cluster, like Hillbrow
    Clinic and Edenvale Hospital, in managing the burden of psychiatric patients at Helen Joseph;
  • The replacement of COVID-19 staff, whose contracts had not been renewed due to a funding shortage; and
  • A fire safety evaluation of the Helen Joseph Hospital, comparable with the one conducted at the CMJAH,

The Gauteng health department’s deputy director-general for corporate services, Basani Baloyi, accepted the memorandum.


City Press article – Patients treated in corridors at Helen Joseph Hospital (Restricted access)


See more from MedicalBrief archives:


DA: Despite R40m security, further thefts delay Charlotte Maxeke casualty's re-opening


DA: 2,000 patients a day unable to be treated at Charlotte Maxeke Hospital


Charlotte Maxeke to fully reopen only in 2023 after ‘at least’ R1bn repair


Serious Adverse Events on the rise in Gauteng's worst hospitals



MedicalBrief — our free weekly e-newsletter

We'd appeciate as much information as possible, however only an email address is required.