Thursday, 11 August, 2022
HomeNews UpdatePhaala warns against prejudice as SA records two monkeypox cases

Phaala warns against prejudice as SA records two monkeypox cases

South Africans should not resort to bigotry around monkeypox, health authorities urged after the country’s first case of the disease was confirmed last week. A second case was confirmed this week.

News24 reports that the first case is a Johannesburg man (30) with no history of international travel, while the second is a 32-year-old man from Cape Town, also with no travel history.

The cases indicate a high likelihood of local transmission, say experts

“The disease only spreads through close droplets, so you cannot get it by being in the same room with an infected person,” said Health Minister Joe Phaahla. “Thus far, it has been dominant in men who have sex with men, but the main feature is that transmission is through close contact.”

Professor Kolela Mlisana, co-chair of the Ministerial Advisory Committee on COVID-19, said anyone was susceptible to infection.

“It does not mean it gets transmitted through men who sleep with men, but through direct contact. The important thing is we are able to diagnose it, and it is going to be important to contact trace. Right now, it is one case and up to us, as lab people, to be on high alert.”

According to a statement by the National Institute for Communicable Diseases (NICD), more than 3,000 people have been diagnosed with monkeypox since May 2022 in several European countries, the United States, Canada, Morocco and the United Arab Emirates. This is the first multi-country outbreak of the disease, according to the NICD and is also the largest outbreak of monkeypox that has been recorded.

The NICD is conducting online, in-service training for health workers to be able to detect the disease: it said it was not very contagious, does not spread in the same way as flu and COVID viruses, and requires close contact like kissing, cuddling or touching one of the monkeypox lesions (sores) to be transmitted.

Symptoms are an acute illness characterised by fever and general flu-like symptoms, followed by the eruption of a blister-like rash on the skin. The disease is rarely fatal, and cases typically resolve within two to four weeks and require no hospital treatment.

“Treatment is symptomatic and a doctor may prescribe medication to treat pain, fever and other discomforts. It is important to keep hydrated, and prevent scratching or bursting the blisters to prevent infection with bacteria. The rash is generally not itchy, but may become itchy when the skin lesions are almost healed,” it said.

The source of the monkeypox cases in South Africa – as well as the links between cases – remain under investigation, according to the Department of Health.

Daily Maverick reports that the NICD is working with the department to assess the risk of local transmission, in collaboration with the WHO and in line with international health regulations.

“The health officials will continue with contact tracing while closely monitoring the situation and alert clinicians on symptoms to look for, and if [the] clinical picture fits with monkeypox, they are urged to complete a case investigation form and send samples for testing,” said the Health Department.

At this stage, the WHO has not proposed any travel restrictions.

In Monday’s situation update, the organisation recommended that any individual feeling unwell – including “having a fever with rash-like illness” – should avoid non-essential travel until declared no longer a public health risk.

Multi-layered screening measures are being employed by port health officials. These include visual observation, temperature screening and the completion of a travellers’ health questionnaire when entering the country through airports, border gates and sea ports.

Spotlight has published answers to 10 common questions about monkeypox.

1. What is monkeypox?
Dr Aida Sivro, senior scientist at the Centre for the Aids programme of Research in South Africa (CAPRISA) tells Spotlight that monkeypox is caused by infection with the monkeypox virus, which belongs to the same family of viruses as the smallpox virus.

According to Sivro, there are two known types of monkeypox virus – the West African Clade and the Central African Clade. The current outbreak is caused by the less severe West African Clade. The World Health Organisation (WHO) has an extensive fact sheet on monkeypox that provides more information.

2. What are the symptoms and disease progression?
The incubation period for the disease is six to 13 days and the infection is divided into two periods – the first being characterised by general symptoms such as fever and the second by a skin rash or lesions.

Sivro explains that the symptoms of monkeypox typically include fever, headache, muscle and back pain, fatigue, swollen lymph nodes and skin rash or lesions.

The WHO stated that the rash occurs about one to three days after the fever starts and is normally found on the face and extremities. The rash then becomes lesions, which progress to pustules that eventually become crusts that dry up and fall off. Symptoms can last from two to four weeks.

3. How deadly is it?
Monkeypox is not considered very deadly. According to the WHO, the recent case fatality ratio has been around three to 6%. A case fatality ratio (CFR) refers to the proportion of deaths among people diagnosed with a specific disease over a certain period.

Severe cases are more common among children and those with immune deficiencies. However, there is a range of complications that can occur, including secondary infections, bronchopneumonia, sepsis, encephalitis and infection of the cornea.

4. How is it treated?
During a press briefing on monkeypox by the NICD, Principal Medical Scientist Dr Jacqueline Weyer explained that typically the disease resolves itself without any specific interventions. She said doctors normally only treat the patient’s symptoms and discomfort like fever and rash. Typically, due to the mild nature of the disease, no specific treatment or hospitalisation is required in most cases.

According to Sivro, there is no specific treatment for monkeypox, but due to its genetic similarity to the smallpox virus, antiviral drugs for smallpox can be used to treat it. Currently, there are two FDA-approved drugs for treatment of smallpox, known as TPOXX (tecovirimat) and Tembexa (brincidofovir). According to the WHO, Tecovirimat was licensed for the treatment of monkeypox in 2022 but it is not yet widely available. Neither of these antivirals is listed as registered on the SAHPRA website.

5. Is there a vaccine against it?
Sivro says that there is no specific vaccine against monkeypox but because it is similar to the smallpox virus, vaccines against smallpox are effective for use against monkeypox.

“Based on data from previous outbreaks in Africa, smallpox vaccines are thought to be around 85% effective against monkeypox,” she says. “There is currently only one FDA-approved smallpox vaccine used for the prevention of monkeypox disease – JYNNEOS, also known by the brand names Imvamune and Imvanex.”

She added that it is believed that vaccination after monkeypox exposure if given within four days could help prevent early-onset or if given between four and 14 days after exposure, it could make the disease less severe.

There is a candidate vaccine specifically against monkeypox that is currently under development, according to Professor Derseree Archary, Senior Scientist in Mucosal Immunology at CAPRISA, but it is still in the early stages of development.

6. When and why did smallpox vaccination stop in South Africa?
After smallpox was eradicated in 1980 due to a global vaccination campaign, routine vaccination against smallpox among the general public was halted.

Archary says the exact date that South Africa stopped vaccinating against smallpox is hard to find and confirm but she thinks it was in 1982.

During the NICD press briefing Professor Adrian Puren, acting director of the NICD, said that while he isn’t sure of the exact date that South Africa stopped vaccinating against smallpox, people younger than 40 to 50 are thought not to be immune to smallpox.
Sivro added: “It is generally believed that individuals vaccinated for smallpox before (the) 1980s still have some level of immunity. However, it is difficult to predict how much protection this would provide against monkeypox infection and disease.”

7. Is the smallpox vaccine available in South Africa?
Spotlight asked the South African Health Products Regulatory Authority (SAHPRA) whether a smallpox vaccine is currently registered and available in South Africa.

“There are several vaccines that were previously approved for smallpox, although smallpox was no longer a threat and has not been brought into the country by those manufacturers. It is, however, included in the combination vaccines for the general immunisation programme for paediatrics,” says Yuven Gounden, spokesperson for SAHPRA. There is however no smallpox vaccine listed in the childhood immunisation schedules published on the Department of Health’s website.

Gounden adds that SAHPRA has received no submissions to date with regards to plans to approve a smallpox vaccine to prevent monkeypox in South Africa.

Archary says that the older generation smallpox vaccine is registered in South Africa but is not widely available to the public and would only be administered under very strict circumstances.

Sivro adds that smallpox vaccination is being offered in some countries to adults who have been in contact with a confirmed monkeypox case.

8. How is monkeypox transmitted?
According to the WHO factsheet, monkeypox can be transmitted from an infected animal to humans or from one infected person to another.

Puren explains that monkeypox is much less transmissible than some other viruses and requires prolonged close contact between individuals. He added that a person with monkeypox is thought to be contagious for about three days from the time the symptoms start until the skin where the rash or lesions appear is fully healed.

Archary says that due to the DNA of the monkeypox virus being very stable on surfaces, clothes and bed linen contaminated by an infected person can spread the disease. Close personal contact or skin-to-skin contact with the rash of the infected person as well as respiratory secretions like the infected person sneezing on someone could also transmit the virus.

9. Do condoms reduce the risk of contracting monkeypox?
The method of transmission makes it unlikely that condoms will prevent the spread of monkeypox during sexual intercourse. Sivro says that it is currently unclear if monkeypox can spread through semen or vaginal fluids.

However, because of the skin-to-skin contact and fluid exchange during sexual intercourse, condoms will not be protective against monkeypox, says Archary.

10. Why does it appear to be more prevalent among men who have sex with men?
Phaahla said monkeypox is currently dominant among men who have sex with men (MSM). While the data do indicate that most cases in the current outbreak are among MSM, it is vital not to misunderstand this statement.

Weyer explains that there is no evidence that there is a different biological susceptibility to the monkeypox virus and there is no “selection” by the virus in terms of the group of people who are being infected from that perspective. Instead, it is likely that the outbreak occurring in MSM is coincidental.

Archary cautioned against the dialogue that monkeypox is found in MSM and bisexual men, as this is likely to be misinterpreted by the public and could cause stigma against these groups. “This virus will transmit irrespective of sexual preference through close skin-to-skin contact, kissing, coming into contact with contaminated clothes, bed linen, through respiratory secretions from an infectious person sneezing on you, etcetera. Currently, there are some studies being pursued to understand what the transmission dynamics are during sexual intercourse and we await those data,” she says.


Spotlight article – Monkeypox: Our top 10 questions answered (Creative Commons Licence)


News24 article – Experts warn against prejudice as first monkeypox case reported (Open access)


Daily Maverick article – Second monkeypox case identified in SA, now in Western Cape (Open access)


See more from MedicalBrief archives:


WHO to rename monkeypox to ‘combat racism and stigma’


Monkeypox possibly linked to decrease in smallpox vaccine – global experts


UK reports first case of monkeypox, probably from Nigeria


CDC expresses concern over monkeypox outbreak in UK




MedicalBrief — our free weekly e-newsletter

We'd appeciate as much information as possible, however only an email address is required.