The latest trial over the death of Argentine football legend Diego Maradona was suspended last week after claims that kidney test results presented to the court came from his father, reports France24.
Seven healthcare workers are accused of criminal negligence over the care Maradona received before his death at 60 in November 2020, while he was recuperating from brain surgery.
The first trial was dramatically annulled last year after two and a half months of hearings, and revelations that one of the judges overseeing it took part in a clandestine documentary about the case.
A new trial began in April. It had been nearing a close when it, too, became embroiled in controversy.
The defence claimed that kidney test evidence produced at the trial belonged to Maradona’s father – also named Diego, who died in 2015 – and not the star of the 1986 World Cup.
The court adjourned until 27 August to check whether the tests “correspond to Diego Armando Maradona or someone else”, presiding judge Alberto Gaig said.
Maradona died of heart failure and acute pulmonary oedema at a rented home in Buenos Aires two weeks after undergoing surgery for a brain clot. His medical team is accused of providing inadequate care in the lead-up to his death.
It has denied the charges.
The prosecution argued that the alleged test mix-up in no way jeopardised their case. “They (the defence) will not succeed in bringing down the trial,” prosecutor Patricio Ferrari said.
If confirmed that the test results were those of Maradona’s father, however, it could discredit the medical commission set up to evaluate the circumstances of Maradona’s death, boosting the defence.
The commission has been highly critical of the care Maradona received in his last days.
Last Tuesday, a nephrologist testified that the former player, who had a history of cocaine abuse, was suffering from chronic kidney disease which should have acted as a red flag for his carers. He added that the patient should have undergone daily blood tests but that there was no evidence of any blood being taken during his two weeks of home convalescence.
Experts’ credibility in question
Agustin Varela, a lawyer for one of the accused, nurse Nancy Forlini, noted that the some of the kidney tests dated back to 2015 and could not have been Maradona the player’s because he was not living in Argentina at the time.
Maradona spent most of that year in Dubai before travelling to Argentina to see his father, Diego Salustiano Maradona, who died in June 2015.
Another of Forlini's lawyers, Nicolas D’Albora, has denied any plans to seek a mistrial. “I want this case to end so that my client knows her judicial fate,” he said.
France24 article – Maradona trial on hold over possible medical evidence mix-up (Open access)
See more from MedicalBrief archives:
Court declares mistrial in negligence case over Maradona’s death
Medics who treated Maradona on trial for homicide