From incontinence to chronic pain, millions of women around the world are still suffering from childbirth complications many decades later, writes Melissa Hogenboom for the BBC.
It’s 2024 and I’m in the hospital, again. I’ve been in pain that even morphine can’t touch for about 36 hours. When they open me up, the surgeons find parts of my bowel have protruded into a gap in my stomach lining. It’s caused it to perforate, leaving pus inside my entire abdomen, resulting in a dangerous infection.
The pain is blinding. I am retching periodically though I haven’t eaten for two days.
The surgery takes five hours. I wake up at midnight, groggy in the ICU, with a 15cm incision from my belly button to my pelvis and a large drainage tube in my abdomen.
How did I get here? And what does this have to do with childbirth?
While it’s well known that childbirth can be dangerous, less mentioned are the physical issues that can last beyond those early years and affect women even decades later. While my own situation is rare, childbirth complications that appear later in life are alarmingly common.
It’s been estimated that globally, around 40m women per year are affected by complications that last months or years. These can range from urinary and faecal incontinence to chronic pain, or even scar tissue that can cause life-threatening bowel problems or interfere with future fertility.
Some, like mine, don’t show up until years later and can persist indefinitely. I spoke to several women, and experts, to get a full picture of the lasting physical and mental damage childbirth can cause. I heard how women often feel they aren’t listened to, or worse, feel they had no way to access treatment.
Lifesaving interventions, lifelong effects
Childbirth is risky and can lead to complications or worse, for mother and child. Luckily maternal deaths have become rarer in many parts of the world: between 2000 and 2023, the ratio of maternal deaths to live births having dropped by 40% globally.
Yet the focus on reducing maternal deaths has meant that the longer-term effects of labour and childbirth often receive too little attention, according to a major 2024 global review by international researchers.
Joshua Vogel, a perinatal epidemiologist at the Burnet Institute in Australia and lead author of the review, said it’s worrying how many women are unable to advocate for support for themselves, especially because it can be unclear what is normal, and what should be looked at.
“These complications can be mind-bogglingly diverse,” he says.
Adhesions
In my case, things began with an emergency Caesarean section. Four days after my daughter was born, I was back in hospital undergoing another emergency surgery. My stitches had come undone and I suffered a serious complication with my bowels. It was traumatic and classed as a medical “never event” as it was so rare.
Seven years passed, including another pregnancy, and everything seemed normal.
Then one afternoon I had an onset of sudden abdominal pain that gradually worsened. I texted my husband: “It’s really bad, I can see my stomach moving.”
I thought I had a bad stomach bug. In hindsight, I realise I was no longer thinking rationally. That’s perhaps why I somehow mustered the energy to collect the children from school, even lifting my child’s bike into my car.
But the pain just got worse. Eventually, my husband, who was away, contacted his sister – a doctor. She said it could be adhesions – scar tissue – from my Caesarean, causing an obstruction within my intestines. When I began vomiting, she told me to call an ambulance. There were none available so I took a taxi, even though I could barely stand.
At the hospital, a bowel obstruction was confirmed. The original Caesarean, followed by the medical error that led to my second surgery, had left substantial scar tissue inside my abdomen, which was now constricting the flow of blood to my bowels.
Sometimes obstructions disappear on their own, so I spent an excruciating 36 hours waiting to see if I would need surgery. On the second day, my temperature spiked and blood tests showed the levels of C-reactive protein, a marker of inflammation, had risen dangerously from 1 to 311 (a normal level is below 5). The decision was made to operate as soon as possible (another painful five hours…).
Afterwards, the surgeon told me the surgery had gone well, though it was more complex than anticipated. They cut out 60cm of the part of my bowel that had been deprived of blood and oxygen, but the surgery had saved my life. Again, with time I healed well and the stoic in me thought, “It could have been worse.”
But the medical complications were not over.
Major abdominal surgery
Worldwide, C-sections are on the rise and account for about 21% of all births. In some countries this figure rises to 58% (Dominican Republic). In the US it’s more than 32%.
Caesarean sections can be vital to protect the health of mother and child, but they can have an increased risk of complications, says Soo Downe, professor of midwifery at the University of Lancashire.
When there are complications, they may not materialise immediately. A US study that followed 43 646 mothers for 50 years found that those who had C-sections had a 16% higher risk of dying during that time than those who delivered vaginally. They also had a higher risk of dying from cardiovascular disease, diabetes, respiratory disease, infections and kidney disease.
Stefanie Hinkle, a perinatal epidemiologist from the University of Pennsylvania in the US and co-author of the study, says it isn’t yet clear why. Women who had Caesareans were more likely to be older, have a higher BMI, smoke, or have diabetes or other pre-existing conditions, but the link remained after the researchers accounted for these factors.
One possibility is that a Caesarean is a marker of poorer overall health.
“Another is that the surgery itself affects long-term health, for example through complications like infection, blood clots or cardiovascular events, or through scar tissue and complications in later pregnancies,” says Hinkle.
Clearly, there are numerous long-term risks associated with C-sections. They can result in a greater risk of an ectopic pregnancy, while scarring from Caesareans can increase the risk of placental accreta, where the placenta attaches too deeply into the wall of the uterus.
Lifelong risk
In a cruel irony, the surgical treatment I needed after the first bowel obstruction created yet more scar tissue inside my abdomen. That’s why four months later, the same issue occurred and I was back in the theatre for another emergency operation. Luckily there was no infection or perforation as the team opened me up that same day.
I was told it could happen again tomorrow, several decades later or never again, as I now have a lifelong risk of future occurrences.
Anyone who undergoes abdominal surgery can develop scar tissue, as my case shows.
One 2017 study of women from Sweden found that 37% of women who had previously had a Caesar had abdominal adhesions, compared with 10% of women who hadn’t had one before.
As adhesions can bind internal organs together, they can cause abdominal pain and bowel obstructions, and a slight increased risk of maternal and infant mortality in future pregnancies, a risk that’s higher in an emergency delivery.
Adhesions can also make further Caesarean sections surgically complicated, increasing the risk of bladder and bowel lacerations.
Vaginal births – lasting physical damage
Numerous complications can arise with vaginal births too.
Heather Barnes suffered from a fourth-degree tear when her daughter was born more than 40 years ago. This means that the anal sphincter is torn – as well as the lining of the anus or rectum.
Barnes lives with chronic pain and complications. Forceps were used to help get her daughter out as she was stuck, but this has caused her to have faecal incontinence, perineal pain and pudendal nerve damage.
Her experience is far from unique. Both urinary and faecal incontinence are extremely common in the decades after childbirth, particularly in women who give birth vaginally. One study looking at women 20-26 years after childbirth, found that 61% experienced urinary incontinence, 22% had faecal incontinence and 17% had symptoms of pelvic organ prolapse.
Suzanne Hagen, a professor of health services research at Glasgow Caledonian University in the UK and lead author of the study, says that what’s not visible in these statistics is the devastating effects these problems have on these women's lives, on their relationships and their ability to work.
Barnes, for instance, felt too traumatised to have another child and was not able to return to work. “The stress of always knowing at any time I could have an accident is just so awful,” she told me. At the time, no one spoke about incontinence or pain. “You didn’t even tell your best friend,” she says.
It’s estimated that up to 90% of women will have at least some some tearing, grazing or an episiotomy – the cut between the vagina and anus, to create a larger opening for the baby’s head – during vaginal childbirth. Births requiring instruments like forceps or ventouse, attached to the baby’s head using suction, are associated with significantly higher rates of tears.
Deeper tears come with a higher risk of urinary or faecal incontinence, pain during sex, or a need for reconstructive surgery.
Women of South Asian origin are at higher risk of vaginal tears, a fact that Kajal Da Silva, a mother of one, was not aware of until she suffered a fourth-degree tear.
“It’s as if your whole life then revolves around your injury still,” says Da Silva, now six years later. “I wouldn’t be able to make plans without figuring out what I’m going to eat, what I eat, what I’m doing the next day, planning my journey to make sure there’s a toilet en route."
Da Silva still has chronic pelvic pain, can’t sit and stand for long, and does not plan on having any more children.
Chronic pain
Whether a delivery was vaginal or Caesarean, pain is common in the years after childbirth. This can be caused by damage to the pudendal nerve, which runs through the pelvis and controls movement and sensation to that area, including the genitals, anus, and urethra.
It’s well-documented that women’s pain is not always taken seriously by healthcare professionals. A 2024 UK report on birth trauma, for example, mentions an incident where an obstetrician reportedly told a midwife that “women do not have nerves in their vagina” while stitching a patient who had not been given adequate pain relief.
Barnes said she only found out about pudendal nerve pain from a newspaper.
“No one believed that I’d really got pain,” she says.
Mental health
Some consequences of childbirth that endure are not physical, but psychological. The two are known to be linked. Indeed, a negative experience of childbirth is recognised as a major risk factor for developing mental health problems after birth, as well as a persistent fear of childbirth.
While there’s now greater awareness of postnatal mental health in the year after birth, less understood is that many women continue to suffer with their mental health years later.
One analysis found that about 4.5% of women continued to have depressive symptoms throughout the three-year follow up period. About 10%-15% of new mothers are estimated to have depression, the most common postpartum mental health condition, while other conditions include anxiety, post-traumatic stress disorder and postpartum psychosis.
Advocating for support
There’s no quick fix for many of the complications after childbirth, but knowing what support is available can be an important first step.
In a 2019 report looking into women’s experiences of care after pelvic organ prolapse, UK researchers found that many delayed seeking help, partly because they felt embarrassed or felt their symptoms were dismissed. One woman suffered for 30 years before seeking help. A major reason is because it’s common for care to focus on the baby, and not on the mother, meaning women often feel alone or lack information and support.
Part of the problem is that women are usually only offered a few check-ups after birth, says Vogel, meaning any lingering issues afterwards can be missed.
One recent survey found that women overwhelmingly felt that there was “a need for extended follow up” a year post birth. Of course, many new parents simply don’t have the time to think about themselves at all when caring for a child.
This is coupled with misconceptions about the period after childbirth. “There’s the expectation that some discomfort or impaired function is normal,” says Vogel.
* Hogenboom is author of Breadwinners and The Motherhood Complex
See more from MedicalBrief archives:
Global experts flag high mortality rates linked to pregnancy
Misinformation on postpartum depression ‘risks lives’
Perinatal depression: mums, dads, babies all at risk – London meta-analysis
Gqeberha obs/gynae’s R4.5m settlement over mother’s injuries
SA’s ‘too high’ Caesarean birth rate must be reversed
Respectful maternity care can save South African lives – Lancet
