DA used PAI Act to flush out details of hospital serious adverse events

Organisation: Position: Deadline Date: Location:

The opposition Democratic Alliance has had to use the Promotion of Access to Information Act to obtain the statistics of Serious Adverse Events at Gauteng hospitals.

The country’s largest health facility‚ Chris Hani Baragwanath Academic Hospital (CHBAH)‚ does a good job despite high patient numbers. The Times reports that this was according to the Gauteng Health Department in response to the disclosure that it recorded 62 cases of “serious adverse events” in 2015. The Soweto-based hospital manages about 592‚000 outpatients yearly‚ 51‚000 normal hours casualties and 21‚500 after hours casualties‚ the department said. The facility also performs around 8‚000 caesarean section deliveries in addition to 19‚000 live births annually.

“The hospital personnel takes a great care in managing each patient but‚ unfortunately‚ Serious Adverse Events (SAEs) do happen from time to time. For 2015 the hospital reported 62 SAEs cases of 586 cases that were recorded for all hospitals and clinics in the province‚” the department said. Serious Adverse Events include allegations of negligence‚ human errors‚ abscondment of patients and system

Th report says the other three academic hospitals accounted for fewer SAEs in 2015 – ten at the Charlotte Maxeke Johannesburg Academic Hospital‚ nine at the George Mukhari Academic Hospital and three at the Steve Biko Academic Hospital.

“In each SAE case‚ progressive discipline such as verbal or written warning‚ suspension with or without pay and dismissal is instituted‚” the department said. “In other instance cases are referred to statutory bodies such as South African Nursing Council and Health Professions Council of South Africa.

“To minimise serious adverse events‚” the department said it has put plans in place‚ which include: all units are expected to conduct continuous risk assessments and clinical audits at least once a month; monitoring and evaluation of clinical practice through assessments using the National Core Standards; ongoing reviews of the midwifery practice standards; management in each facility to place emphasis on consequent management upon completion of investigations; and Gauteng is currently piloting implementation of Continuous Professional Development to enhance clinical skills and competence of nurses.

The department did not state what types of incidents had occurred.

The report said Jack Bloom‚ the DA’s health spokesperson who obtained the statistics from the Gauteng Department of Health after submitting a request using the Promotion of Access to Information Act‚ said the hospitals with the lowest SAEs are: Heidelberg – one SAE; Edenvale – two SAEs; Tambo Memorial – three SAEs; and Rahima Moosa – four SAEs.

Bloom noted that the “most improved hospital is Tembisa‚ which had 17 SAEs in 2015‚ down from 71 SAEs recorded from January 2012 to September 2013”.

With a total of 503 SAEs in Gauteng state hospitals in 2015‚ Bloom said in the report: “More steps are needed to cut down medical mistakes and ensure that patients are healed rather than injured in our state hospitals.”


Bloom said: “Jubilee Hospital is the most dangerous hospital in Gauteng as it recorded 51 SAEs despite being much smaller than Baragwanath Hospital.”

A Randfontein Herald report says other dangerous hospitals include the following: Pholosong – 46 SAEs; Leratong – 30 SAEs; Kopanong and Odi – 28 SAEs; Pretoria West – 23 SAEs; Sebokeng – 22 SAEs; and Far East Rand – 21 SAEs.


The Times report
Gauteng Health statement
Randfontein Herald report

Receive Medical Brief's free weekly e-newsletter

Related Posts

Thank you for subscribing to MedicalBrief

MedicalBrief is Africa’s premier medical news and research weekly newsletter. MedicalBrief is published every Thursday and delivered free of charge by email to over 33 000 health professionals.

Please consider completing the form below. The information you supply is optional and will only be used to compile a demographic profile of our subscribers. Your personal details will never be shared with a third party.

Thank you for taking the time to complete the form.