Top UK GP forced to resign from NHS over ‘inflammatory’ comments

Organisation: Position: Deadline Date: Location:

One of Britain’s most senior GPs was forced to resign from his role as NHS England’s director of primary care, after it was revealed he had been anonymously posting ‘inflammatory’ comments about doctors online, reports The Independent.

Dr Arvind Madan caused outrage among family doctors after his comments came to light in an interview with a doctor’s magazine.

The report says the London-based GP had been leaving posts under stories on the magazine’s website under the pseudonym “Devil’s Advocate” for a number of years, often speaking out in favour of NHS England policies.

Madan is quoted as saying that he had been seeking to “provoke a more balanced discussion” by challenging negative views and conspiracy theories aired by of the some commenters. However, readers of the magazine were able to work out his identity when he posted clarifications on articles he had written using his real name, with his “Devil’s Advocate” pseudonym. He routinely commented on recent closures of GP practices, saying those remaining should be “pleased” that less viable businesses were shut. The report says an analysis has found that these closures have meant more than 1m patients have had to find new doctors, and have stretched the remaining practices to breaking point in some towns.

Other comments took aim at doctors complaining about workload pressures and mounting costs. He said: “We can get six figure salaries for working four days a week, 45 weeks a year. Run that past the general public and see how much sympathy you get.” When asked in an interview if these were views he still stood by Madan did not disavow them, but he announced he would be standing down early from his position at NHS England.

“(My) secondment comes to an end later this year, but it is clear to me that, sadly, I have lost the confidence of some of my colleagues, and I have therefore decided to resign my NHS England position,” he said. “As part of my attempts to challenge the negative views – and even conspiracy theories – held by a small but vocal minority in the profession I posted on an anonymous online forum used by GPs.

“It was never my intention to cause offence but rather to provoke a more balanced discussion about contentious issues acting as a devil’s advocate.”

He added: “I wish to make it categorically clear that these comments are not a reflection of NHS England policy, and it is now clear to me that trying to move the debate on in this way is not compatible with my role as director of primary care. Supporting general practice is too important an issue to allow it to be mired in unnecessary controversy.

“I would like to apologise unreservedly to those who have been upset, particularly in smaller practices.”

The report says NHS England did not comment on his resignation.

However, the British Medical Association (BMA) has written to it demanding action against Madan for his damaging comments, although a spokesperson for the health service body said it has not received this yet. Deputy chair of the BMA’s GP committee, Dr Mark Sanford-Wood said: “Dr Madan’s damaging comments caused significant anger amongst the profession at a time when GPs require support from NHS England. It is only right that he has therefore done the right thing and offered his resignation.”

The Independent report
Pulse interview


Receive Medical Brief's free weekly e-newsletter



Related Posts

Thank you for subscribing to MedicalBrief


MedicalBrief is Africa’s premier medical news and research weekly newsletter. MedicalBrief is published every Thursday and delivered free of charge by email to over 33 000 health professionals.

Please consider completing the form below. The information you supply is optional and will only be used to compile a demographic profile of our subscribers. Your personal details will never be shared with a third party.


Thank you for taking the time to complete the form.