HomeHealth governanceLiquidated firm subcontracts R35m NHI contract to itself

Liquidated firm subcontracts R35m NHI contract to itself

A company awarded a plum tender by the National Department of Health to handle NHI health and wellness event management went into liquidation before receiving its first payment, so just sub-contracted another entity within the group instead – and claimed management fees on top of that, reports News24.

According to court documents, Dot Design Agency “did not have the ability to execute the orders”, because it was placed in final liquidation before receiving its first payment. So Dots Design director Musa Likobo instead simply appointed another of his companies to execute the contract on its behalf while it was being wound up.

The contract was structured so that the service provider could subcontract work it could not carry out and then claim a 9.5% management fee on top, raising questions about the liquidator’s oversight of this arrangement, given Likobo’s claim in court papers that the liquidator agreed to the subcontracting structure.

The NDoH had awarded Dots Design a R540 “per transaction” contract that ballooned to R35m, all while the company was in liquidation.

KMTV Media – directed by former City Press editor Khathu Mamaila, and which shares a business address with political party Azapo – was awarded a R1 620 “per transaction” contract, which ballooned to R146m.

Both contracts totalled R182m and had no cap, while the funds were drawn from critical health programmes, including HIV/Aids, TB, child nutrition, and an NHI budget.

The NDoH referred the matter to the Special Investigating Unit (SIU) and the Auditor-General (AGSA), which have already found material non-compliance.

Likobo did not respond to News24’s request for comment.

‘Implementing agent’

Court papers from Dots Design’s liquidation case, brought by the Midlands Home Owners Association and ABSA Bank in the Free State High Court (Bloemfontein), detail how Likobo worked around the fact that his company could not fulfil its obligations.

In papers filed in March 2026, Likobo admitted he had appointed another of his companies, Dots Design Group, as an “implementing agent” to carry out Dots Agency’s NDoH contract.

Dots Group is a separate company registered at the same address, with Likobo as its sole director. It was incorporated in August 2020 – while Dots Agency was already in financial distress.

Likobo told the court Dots Agency “did not have the ability to execute the orders” and that Ruwayne Smith, the liquidator, agreed to the arrangement “because he was convinced of this very ability”.

A company in liquidation cannot receive money into its business account – all money must go through a liquidator’s estate account. It also cannot trade until the Master’s Office gives permission, which Dots Agency only got in November 2025.

The Companies Act states: “Every disposition of its property (including rights of action) by any company being wound-up and unable to pay its debts made after the commencement of the winding-up, shall be void unless the court otherwise orders.”

Ministry of Justice spokesperson Palesa Rammitlwa told News24 the liquidators must reflect payments in the liquidation and distribution account.

National Health Department spokesperson Foster Mohale told News24 the department never received notice to change Dots Agency’s banking details, was not notified of the liquidators’ appointment, and was unaware of the company’s liquidation status or inability to execute the work.

“We are hearing this for the first time, and if they lied to the department, the investigative agencies will uncover this and recommend remedial actions,” he said.

How the subcontracting arrangement worked

If Dots Agency used the subcontracting method, it was paid for the work Dots Group performed – with a 9.5% fee added – while a separate company controlled by Likobo executed the actual work.

Despite being in liquidation, Dots Design had “generated R30.3m revenue and accumulated between R4m and R7.4m in cash while in liquidation”, Likobo told the court, calling it “objective evidence of viability, not speculation”.

He had used this to argue Dots Agency was still viable and asked the court to place it in business rescue. This was dismissed, and the company was placed in final liquidation in August 2024.

Likobo launched a third attempt in March 2026. He said that the Health Department contract would be worth R450m over three years, but an appointment letter seen by News24 shows it was worth “R540 per transaction”, and Mohale also denied this.

Mohale did not confirm whether the department paid Dots Design for services executed by another company plus the management fee.

“For services like catering, marquees, ablution facilities, even if they are locally sourced, the department still paid Dots Design Agency, which [then] paid those they subcontracted to,” he said.

“The department appointed the service provider based on meeting the minimum requirements as stipulated in the tender adverts. The department never foresaw any events management being unable to be implemented. However, if the company chose to outsource any work, it is up to them,” Mohale added.

Asked whether the department had conducted its own probe or attempted to determine whether the money was irregular, Mohale said: “The department has written to the SIU and the Auditor-General asking them to take over this investigation.”

He said all money paid was for approved projects, but if investigation agencies find money should be recouped, the department would “gladly do so”. Without formal notice of Dots Design’s financial woes, the department “had no basis to suspect, investigate, or withhold payment”.

Smith told News24: “The liquidators have conducted the administration in accordance with the provisions of the Insolvency Act read with the Companies Act. All required permission and/or other form of consent have been obtained to ensure the proper execution of our duties.”

Government contracts

In court papers, Likobo also claimed that Dots Design had signed a R600m contract with the Department of Home Affairs in May 2024 – Aaron Motsoaledi’s final month as Minister. That contract “is still in force”, Likobo said, and “the company’s current positive trading trend while in liquidation is attributable to this contract”.

But Ndileka Cola, spokesperson for the Department of Home Affairs, denied this.

KMTV was appointed to a Home Affairs communications panel in May 2022, under Motsoaledi’s tenure. Two years later, in May 2024, the Health department, under Joe Phaahla, awarded both companies the R182m contract. A month later, Motsoaledi became Minister of Health.

This was also while liquidation proceedings were under way against Dots Design – served in March 2023 and provisionally liquidated in June 2024.

“The Minister … doesn’t get involved in the work of awarding tenders or contracts in any of departments in which he has been,” Mohale said. The Minister and Deputy Minister “do not know anybody in Dots Design” but have previously stated that they have known Mamaila for 32 years, dating back to his time as head of the Sowetan Bureau in Polokwane.

Motsoaledi must account for botched contract

The DA wants Motsoaledi to appear before the Portfolio Committee on Health to explain the awarding of the R35m contract to a company already in liquidation.

Additionally, said the party’s health spokesperson Michele Clarke, he should also account for the hefty contract awarded for NHI health and wellness marketing, and justify why such substantial amounts were to be spent on advertising while critical healthcare programmes remain underfunded.

In a statement, she said the contracts were awarded during the tenure of Phaahla, a month before Motsoaledi returned to the position, and while Motsoaledi did not oversee the original awards, “he is now responsible for ensuring that the Department accounts for what happened and that those responsible face consequences”.

“Serious questions remain about how the department conducted its due diligence when awarding these contracts, particularly how a multimillion-rand contract could be awarded to a company reportedly in liquidation and facing severe financial difficulties.

“The DA will call on Minister Motsoaledi to account before Parliament for the expenditure, explain what due diligence was conducted, and identify who authorised the contracts. We will also demand that those responsible for any wrongdoing are held accountable and that funds intended for healthcare delivery are protected.”

 

News24 article – How a liquidated firm subcontracted its R35m NHI contract to itself (Restricted access)

 

See more from MedicalBrief archives:

 

Questions over NHI advertising contracts spark investigations

 

NHI scheme will open doors to corruption

 

Unpacking the Health Department’s response to NHI ad spending

 

NHI’s R182m spin deal a sign of things to come?

 

With each corruption scandal, public distrust of NHI grows

MedicalBrief — our free weekly e-newsletter

We'd appreciate as much information as possible, however only an email address is required.