In the United Kingdom, lockdown was a risk factor for increasing alcohol consumption in people with alcohol use disorders and relapse for those who had been abstinent, according to researchers from Imperial College London and the NHS Trust at St Mary’s Hospital in London, writing in The Lancet Gastroenterology& Hepatology.
“Those who do relapse are at a high risk of harmful drinking and require a tailored approach for follow-up and intervention,” write authors Jin Un Kim, Amir Majid, Rebekah Judge, Peter Crook, Rooshi Nathwani, Nowlan Selvapatt and others.
“Support from alcohol liaison services could prevent relapse during lockdown.”
Effect of COVID-19 lockdown on alcohol consumption in patients with pre-existing alcohol use disorder
The Lancet Gastroenterology& Hepatology. Published on 4 August 2020.
Authors
Jin Un Kim, Amir Majid, Rebekah Judge, Peter Crook, Rooshi Nathwani, Nowlan Selvapatt, James Lovendiski, Pinelopi Manousou, Mark Thursz, Ameet Dhar, Heather Lewis, Nikhil Vergis and Maud Lemoine.
Abstract
We agree with the Editorial in the July, 2020, issue of The Lancet Gastroenterology & Hepatology, which emphasised the concerning long-term implications of lockdowns implemented to flatten the epidemic curve of COVID-19 on the health behaviour of individuals with alcohol-use disorder.
A complex interplay of heightened financial difficulties, social isolation, uncertainty about the future, and the redistribution of the health workforce and the disruption to clinical services could contribute to increased alcohol intake and relapse under lockdown conditions, and, subsequently, contribute to further liver-associated complications via direct injury or through late presentations to the appropriate services.
Lockdown is a complex social phenomenon that provokes different behavioural responses: a population survey of 1555 active drinkers in the UK identified that 21% increased alcohol consumption during the lockdown, while 35% reduced their alcohol intake.
The true effect of the lockdown on alcohol intake remains unknown because of a paucity of qualitative data.
The study
Two months after lockdown was declared in the UK (23 March 2020), we did a cross-sectional telephone survey of patients with pre-existing alcohol disorders registered since 2017 in the alcohol clinic of St Mary's Hospital, London.
From 21 May to 10 June 2020, 322 (70%) of 462 patients from the database were contacted and 182 (57%) agreed to participate. The survey was done in English using a standardised questionnaire by two trained clinicians.
Participants were mainly male (133 [73%] men, 49 [27%] women) and of white ethnicity (141 [78%]), with a median age of 57 years (IQR 49–66). 42 (23%) of the 182 participants were hazardous drinkers and 71 (39%) were moderate-severe alcohol users before lockdown, as assessed by AUDIT score.
Of the 182 participants, 43 (24%) reported an increase in their alcohol intake, with a mean increase in the AUDIT score of 57·6%, and a mean weekly consumption of 82·5 units. 34 (19%) reported a decrease in their alcohol intake.
Although some parameters such as age, mood and some social conditions differed between those who had increased, decreased, or had an unchanged consumption of alcohol during the lockdown, a multivariate analysis identified only the pre-lockdown AUDIT score and percentage change of AUDIT score from before to during lockdown as factors associated with increased alcohol intake during lockdown.
69 (38%) patients were classified as abstinent before lockdown, with a mean abstinence period of 19·5 months (SD 22). Of this subgroup, 12 (17%) relapsed during lockdown. Mean AUDIT score within the relapse group at the time of our survey was 15·7 (SD 9·6), representing a 226% mean increase from before lockdown, with a mean weekly consumption of 48·8 units (SD 63) during lockdown.
Of the 113 individuals who were previously drinking before the lockdown, 14 (12%) became newly abstinent since the beginning of lockdown.
Among all participants, 55 (30%) had either a virtual or face-to-face contact with the clinic during lockdown; 19 (44%) of the 43 individuals who had increased alcohol consumption had a clinic appointment, compared with 36 (26%) of the 139 individuals with decreased alcohol consumption or for whom consumption remained the same (p=0·035; odds ratio [OR] 0·586, 95% CI 0·378–0·908).
Of the subgroup of patients who had a virtual or face-to-face consultation during the lockdown, 13 (24%) had contact specifically with an alcohol specialist nurse. Univariate analysis revealed that those who had contact with a specialist nurse were more likely to become newly abstinent, compared with those who did not have contact (two [100%] of two vs two [12%] of 17; p=0·035; OR 1·118, 95% CI 0·032–0·432); a positive trend was observed for reduced relapse during lockdown, occurring after alcohol nurse contact (six [18%] of 33 vs three [60%] of five; p=0·075; OR 0·303, 95% CI 0·110–0·839).
Some findings
We emphasise several points.
First, lockdown causes different behavioural changes on alcohol intake, with about 20% of individuals increasing or decreasing their normal alcohol consumption. Although psychosocial distress has been well recognised as a risk of relapse and increased alcohol consumption, the reduction might be associated with decreased financial ability and the decreased availability of on-site alcohol areas (eg pubs or bars).
Second, we found no distinct protective factors for relapse, suggesting that pre-lockdown abstinence status is not protective against lockdown-related relapse. The mean duration of abstinence before relapse was long, which has been previously identified as a strong predictor of continuous abstinence. Lockdown might overshadow this paradigm.
Third, those who relapsed had a clinically significant average level of alcohol consumption of nearly 49 units weekly post-relapse, which is concordant with previous studies of a high risk of harmful drinking after relapse.
Finally, in a subgroup of patients who had clinical contact during lockdown, contact with an alcohol nurse specialist was a positive predictor for reducing relapse and improving new abstinence.
Nonetheless, these findings should be interpreted with caution because of the small sample size of this subgroup. Our data represent a cross-sectional perspective of alcohol disorders during COVID-19 lockdown; any further changes that might present if lockdown conditions change remain to be elucidated.
Summary
In summary, lockdown represents a risk factor for increasing alcohol consumption in people with alcohol use disorders and relapse for those who were previously abstinent.
Those who do relapse are at a high risk of harmful drinking and require a tailored approach for follow-up and intervention. Support from alcohol liaison services could prevent relapse during lockdown.
[link url="https://www.thelancet.com/journals/langas/article/PIIS2468-1253(20)30251-X/fulltext"]Effect of COVID-19 lockdown on alcohol consumption in patients with pre-existing alcohol use disorder[/link]