A Manhattan Institute report has revealed that “gender-affirming” mastectomies for patients under 18 are more common than thought, and that at least 50 of the 5 000 to 6 000 double mastectomies in the US from 2017 to 2023 were in patients under 12.
While cross-sex genital surgeries are rare in the US for both adults and minors, mastectomies – also known as “top surgery” in the context of transgender medicine – are widely available to minors and are the most common transgender surgery for this population, reports Unherd.
Although the medical establishment and trans activists have long argued that cross-sex surgeries for children are exceedingly rare, evidence is emerging of a large and growing surgical industry affecting thousands of children, despite the ongoing lack of authoritative data on precisely how many minors are having the procedures.
The new report demonstrates a higher prevalence of “gender-affirming” mastectomies for minors than previous estimates when broken down by year.
One estimate published in the Journal of the American Medical Association found 3 125 “top surgeries” were performed on patients aged 12-18 from 2016 to 2020 – a lower per-year estimate despite including 18-year-olds, which the Manhattan Institute’s data excluded.
A 2022 report from Reuters estimated 776 top surgeries on minors from 2019-2021, a significantly lower per-year estimate.
The actual prevalence of these surgeries is probably considerably higher than the latest estimate, since it relies on health insurance data and therefore does not include procedures obtained without using insurance.
The apparent increase in surgeries in recent years may be related to the growing prevalence of transgender identification among youth, along with the growing popularity of the affirmation approach, which takes children’s self-described transgender identity at face value.
Proponents of cross-sex medical interventions downplay the prevalence of these procedures.
The Human Rights Campaign (HRC) declared last April that “gender affirming surgeries are NOT performed on children”, and the Association of American Medical Colleges wrote, “GAC surgery among youth is rare, experts say”.
Marci Bowers, plastic surgeon and president of the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH), the leasing standard-setting organisation for transgender medical treatments, has made a similar argument. “Surgery really is not done under the age of 18, except in severe cases . . . And even that is rare, I think the estimates are something like 57 surgeries under the age of 18,” he said in 2023.
But their insistence that surgeries for children are rare should not be confused with repudiation of such surgeries. On the contrary, activists strongly oppose restrictions on trans surgeries for kids. When the Biden administration tempered its support for childhood gender transitions by opposing surgeries for minors, there was swift blowback from the trans lobby.
State lawmakers called the move a “betrayal” in a letter to Biden, and the HRC said the decision was “flat out wrong”.
The growing body of evidence demonstrating the availability of irreversible cross sex surgeries for minors is only the latest development chipping away at trans activists’ narrative in the US.
The American Society of Plastic Surgeons recently became the first major medical organisation in the country to publicly reject the GAC model, acknowledging that “the existing evidence base is viewed as low quality/low certainty”, the Manhattan Institute reported.
Previously, the ASPS lobbied against state restrictions on cross-sex treatments for minors.
“The main justification for “gender-affirming care” for minors has been that “all major US medical associations” support it”, Manhattan Institute Fellow Leor Sapir wrote in the report. “But the US consensus now appears to have its first big fracture.”
City Journal article – A Consensus No Longer (Open access)
Unherd article – Report: thousands of US girls underwent trans ‘top surgeries’ (Open access)
See more from MedicalBrief archives:
Texas sued to block investigations into parents over transgender surgery
US court to decide on transgender challenge
Florida bans youth gender-affirming meds and surgery