HomeMedico-LegalBid to ditch medico-legal payouts will discriminate against poor – advocate

Bid to ditch medico-legal payouts will discriminate against poor – advocate

The state's bid to dodge lump sum payouts in medico-legal settlements in favour of a more flexible payment scheme would perpetuate healthcare inequalities in South Africa, argues the legal counsel for the family at the centre of the dispute.

Facing more than R50bn in medico-legal claims from patients, the government is asking the courts to allow it to rather provide further medical treatment to the patients instead of making lump sum payments, reports the Sunday Times.

The Eastern Cape, Gauteng and Limpopo account for 74% of the medical negligence claims, with the Eastern Cape – buckling under the financial weight of claims worth early R20bn – leading the charge in trying to change the system for settling such cases.

The province, with the support of the National Health Department and the other eight provincial departments, has approached the Constitutional Court in its bid to allow it to provide further medical treatment, rather than a cash payout, when a patient suffers harm as a result of negligence.

It is appealing a Supreme Court of Appeals ruling that set aside an Eastern Cape High Court order that would have allowed it to do this in the case of a mother whose child suffered spastic quadriplegic cerebral palsy because of staff negligence at Cecilia Makiwane Hospital in Mdantsane.

Eastern Cape Health MEC Ntandokazi Capa has argued that allowing only for lump-sum settlements is unaffordable for an already constrained sector, and suggested “simple, effective solutions” as an alternative.

“If a plaintiff is negligently injured … the State must treat the injury at a reasonable standard in one of its medical facilities, under compulsion of a court order for as long as the injury subsists,” she said.

“If the State cannot treat the injury in one of its facilities, it may undertake to pay for the treatment in the private sector – for as long as the injury subsists, paying as and when the treatment is required and received.”

In a supporting affidavit, Health Minister Aaron Motsoaledi said an inflexible requirement to pay out damages via a cash lump-sum “is not justifiable in South Africa’s severely constrained fiscal environment”, and that this depletes provincial coffers.

“The only effective remedy available to the province then is to seek an increase in its equitable share of revenue raised nationally, which if granted, would affect the national budget.”

Despite most provinces’ long histories of negligence cases, claims for these are currently not budgeted for. The result is large contingent liabilities being recorded in the annual financial statements of provincial Health Departments.

When the liability is realised, the department is required to pay the full lump-sum upfront from money which would have been used to provide health services.

To corroborate its stance, the government co-opted former National Treasury official Andrew Donaldson – now affiliated with the University of Cape Town – to provide expert evidence.

A former head of the budget office and public finance divisions in the Treasury who played a leading role in the introduction of a medium-term expenditure framework in 1998, Donaldson said the existing medical claims system risks South Africa’s ability to provide public healthcare.

“On present trends, the annual increase in claims already exceeds the real (after inflation) increase in resources available for health service delivery and will soon exceed even the nominal annual increases in resources.

“In these circumstances, continuing to meet medical negligence claims on the basis of full, up-front payment of estimated future medical expenses, would be self-defeating: this cost alone would undermine the capacity of the State to improve health service delivery over time.”

But Wim Trengove, who represents the family of the child at the centre of the landmark case, believes the State’s suggested solution would perpetuate the country’s deep inequalities.

“A mother and baby who suffer wrongful injury, disability, and loss in a private hospital, on the other hand, would be entitled to their full common law rights comprising full compensation for the cost of private healthcare paid in a lump sum,” according to his affidavit.

“It will give them freedom and agency in their choices and in the determination of their future medical care.

“This line of discrimination will in large part run along the lines of affluence and poverty. The more affluent, including those who have medical aid, generally use private hospitals. The less affluent, who do not have medical aid, cannot afford private hospitals and use public hospitals instead. The MEC’s rule will accordingly favour the affluent and discriminate against the poor.”

The outcome of the Constitutional Court case will have a bearing on the recent proposals by the Law Reform Commission, which has recommended medical negligence payouts against the State exceeding R2m be shifted away from large once-off payouts towards structured settlements, with most future damages paid periodically over the lifetime of an injured person.

 

Sunday Times article – ‘Treatment, not cash payouts’: State seeks new remedy in medical negligence claims (Restricted access)

 

See more from MedicalBrief archives:

 

Eastern Cape’s plan to turn tidal wave of negligence claims

 

Eastern Cape Health slammed over negligence claims

 

Questions over Eastern Cape strategy on R29bn in negligence claims

 

 

MedicalBrief — our free weekly e-newsletter

We'd appreciate as much information as possible, however only an email address is required.