Weaknesses in the provincial health system – rather than global factors or manufacturing delays – were likely behind the ongoing shortage of essential medicines countrywide, which was creating havoc, affecting both in and out-patients at government facilities, and critically, mental health patients, with psychiatric wards “turning into war zones”, notes MedicalBrief.
This is the view of Wits University’s public health governance expert Professor Alex van den Heever, who told the Sunday Times that “given there isn’t a similar problem in the private sector and not all provinces have this problem, it would suggest that this is essentially related to the ability of provinces to purchase these products”.
Some of the meds that are low in stock include drugs to treat hypertension, diabetes, HIV, cholesterol, bipolar disorder, depression, epilepsy and asthma, among others.
The Sowetan reports that over-burdened staff are facing burnout as they try to manage aggressive patients without medication, with the shortages of chronic drugs in Gauteng facilities escalating into a psychiatric treatment crisis.
Nurses, a hospital manager and a psychiatrist have warned that the lack of essential sedatives and antipsychotic medication is risking the lives of both patients and healthcare workers.
National Health Department spokesperson Foster Mohale said the shortages apparently stemmed from supply chain disruptions to a range of medicines, but also affecting key psychiatric meds, including olanzapine and quetiapine, and blamed manufacturing delays and global supply disruptions due to the blockage of the Strait of Hormuz.
“Suppliers have cited manufacturing delays linked to difficulties in sourcing active pharmaceutical ingredients, while global freight and logistics challenges have further affected the supply of these medicines,” Mohale said.
However, Van den Heever told the Sunday Times that given the private sector appeared to be unaffected by the situation, it "suggests that their (provincial state departments) non-personnel budgets are close to exhausted, and that could be the limiting factor. When I look at the different provinces, there are extensive levels of irregular expenditure, which suggests corruption. It doesn’t confirm it, but it is strongly suggestive that Health Departments lack proper internal controls and have major gaps in their procurement processes. This results in much of the non-personnel budget being squandered.”
Many provinces, he said, particularly Gauteng and the Eastern Cape, have substantial unpaid bills, so it’s quite possible in many cases that the supply of medicines has stopped because of non-payment.
“It’s more governance weaknesses in the provincial health system than global factors,” said Van den Heever. “If it were global, the private sector would have the same constraints, and there is no indication that that’s the case. Unless there was some evidence of a specific supply logistics problem internationally, it would appear to be locally driven.”
He said the very high levels of irregular expenditure and accruals, and unpaid debts, “are indicative of a systemic failure of governance affecting the internal controls of provincial Health Departments and their financial management as a whole”.
“Looking at the case of Babita Deokaran, it is evident that substantial sums of money are being laundered out of provincial departments, and that is a major part of the problem. A large portion of funds don’t end up productively supplying medicines. That squandering of the non-personnel budget is what creates such constraints, because you can’t afford to pay your bills, and people stop supplying you.
“So I don’t believe this shortage is caused by global factors. I’ve seen nothing to corroborate that. The evidence of a failure of governance – resulting in a failure of controls and systems in the provincial departments – is more likely.”
Dangerous conditions
Psychiatric wards are being hardest hit, with a hospital manager at a Tshwane hospital describing the situation as “the most horrendous experience” of her professional career.
“We do not have the chemical sedatives. We don’t have Ativan and other stabilising medication.”
She said the shortages were creating dangerous conditions for patients and staff, as newly admitted, undiagnosed and relapsed patients became increasingly difficult to manage.
The manager said nurses were regularly assaulted while working in overcrowded wards that were never designed to accommodate large numbers of psychiatric patients.
“We don’t have enough staff. We don’t have security. We don’t have restraints. We are expected to manage psychotic patients without the resources needed to keep everyone safe.”
She said a week rarely passed without a nurse being assaulted.
Unable to stabilise, prevent aggression
A nurse at Weskoppies Psychiatric Hospital, west of Johannesburg, said the shortages were making it increasingly difficult for doctors to stabilise patients.
“When doctors prescribe medication, there is a reason for it based on the patient’s condition. The medication helps us contain aggression and manage symptoms.
“When that medication is out of stock, we start seeing aggression, psychosis and disruptive behaviour again.”
The absence of injectable sedatives was particularly concerning when patients became aggressive, especially in wards with limited staffing.
“Sometimes we rely on security, but by the time they arrive, another patient or nurse may already have been assaulted.”
Crisis extends beyond hospitals
At a clinic in Ekurhuleni, another nurse said healthcare workers were bearing the brunt of frustrated patients who arrived to collect medication only to find it unavailable.
“We are working under very unsafe and unhealthy conditions because patients come to collect their medication, and when they don’t get it, they accuse us of stealing it,” he said.
He said shortages of medication used to manage psychiatric treatment side effects were also causing some patients to abandon their treatment.
“They tell us, ‘If you’re not giving me the medication that helps me stop shaking, I’m not taking any of these tablets’. Then they leave all of their medication behind and walk out,” he said.
At Little Eden, an organisation in Ekurhuleni caring for about 300 people with profound intellectual and physical disabilities, the shortages have also created a significant financial burden.
Chief executive Ann Coetzee said the organisation had spent almost R150 000 in three months on privately buying medication that should have been supplied by the state.
Psychiatrist Dr Kali Tricoridis, who works with Little Eden and another facility caring for people with chronic psychiatric conditions, warned that interruptions could undo months of treatment progress.
She said restarting treatment was equally challenging. “You destroy an entire treatment cycle. It can take weeks to gradually increase a patient back to a therapeutic dose.”
Everyday life-sustaining meds
An elderly patient at Ebony Park Clinic told The Citizen she had repeatedly visited the facility for medication to manage high blood pressure and other illnesses, but had left without receiving the treatment she needed.
A nurse said patients were spending hours waiting to be attended to, only to discover that their medicine was unavailable.
DA Gauteng health spokesperson Madeleine Hicklin said the province had major shortages of BP medication, ARVs, blood thinners, bipolar drugs and insulin.
The DA had demanded answers from Gauteng Health MEC Faith Mazibuko, who had acknowledged the shortages and indicated the department was moving medication between facilities to alleviate the problem.
“She has indicated they are aware of the stock-outs and are trying to alleviate the problems by borrowing medication from one facility for another, but that ultimately does not address the real problems,” Hicklin said.
The shortage of mental health medication was particularly concerning, and she warned that the issue needed to be addressed urgently.
Facilities reporting shortages include Steve Biko Academic Hospital, Charlotte Maxeke Johannesburg Academic Hospital, Nigel Clinic and Northmead Clinic, among others, and Hicklin added that there were also concerns about the medication used to treat chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
Hicklin said Charlotte Maxeke had struggled for months to access Symbicort, a drug used to manage COPD.
One nurse said the shortage of chronic medication was because the government was not managing its administration properly, unlike with its HIV programmes.
“The shortage of HIV-related medication is being addressed speedily because its database is organised. But with other diseases, they don’t even have statistics.”
Beyond Tembisa
On the corruption at Tembisa Hospital being replicated at other hospitals in Gauteng and other provinces, Van den Heever said: “Certainly in Gauteng the problem goes beyond Tembisa. What we’ve not seen is that the investigations associated with Tembisa were properly extended to the whole province. And none of the contractors found to have been involved in the Deokaran matter has been debarred from contracting with the state.
“So these front companies that were set up for purposes of extraction are in all likelihood operating across the system as a whole.”
He was scathing on the role of the national department in the crisis.
“The Minister should be living and breathing this every single day. He’s not. There has been no attempt to address these issues.”
The Citizen article – Bitter pill for the sick as Gauteng clinics run out of meds (Open access)
See more from MedicalBrief archives:
Drug shortages not tied solely to compliance issues, says SAHPRA
Minister urges action on port delays to address medicine shortages
Queues, medicine shortages, plague clinic patients
Drug shortage fears as supply chain challenges persist
Medicine shortages worse a year after President’s interventions
