back to top
Friday, 8 August, 2025
HomeTalking Points

Talking Points

Cannabis oil: 'Dangerous and unsubstantiated claims being made'

Like most people who value individual freedom from government regulation, columnist Ivo Vegter writes in the Daily Maverick that he approves of the worldwide...

Need for more pragmatism over drug use – SA expert

There is a strong need for greater awareness of pragmatic, inclusive approaches to drug use – which are proven to reduce the negative consequences...

Rural doctors bedevilled by politics

Mseleni Provincial Hospital is in the sticks in a distant corner of northern KwaZulu-Natal, yet this remote state hospital is renowned in specialist medical...

New ACP guidelines on how best to treat gout ignites bitter battle among physicians

A bitter battle has broken out among physicians about how best to treat gout, following new guidelines from the American College of Physicians that...

How Iceland engineered the cleanest-living teens in Europe

The Icelandic model, which has turned around the drug and alcohol behaviour of its troubled teens, could benefit the general psychological and physical wellbeing of...

Harvard dispute over whistleblower allegations turns nasty

A bizarre conflict between a mentor and his student spiralled dramatically out of control, damaging the reputation of a prominent scientist and Harvard University,...

Anti-vaxxer Trump may tap anti-vaxxer Kennedy for panel on vaccination safety

US President-elect Donald Trump opened up a new front in his war on science, according to a Boston Globe editorial, when he appointed –...

Clinical trial with 'young blood' to slow ageing is labelled a 'scam'

A pay-to-participate private clinical trial on the potential of 'young' blood plasma from teenagers and young adults can reverse certain of the hallmarks of...

Research shows superiority of US female doctors

Female physicians tend to provide higher-quality medical care than males, according to Harvard research. And if male US doctors were as adept as females,...

First female doctor in the UK spent 56 years disguised as a man

Dr James Barry, an Irish surgeon who served in the Cape Colony in the mid-1800s, and is credited with a number of medical innovations...

Debate on long-term psychiatric drug use

The benefits of psychiatric drugs have been exaggerated and the harms underplayed due to poor trial designs, argues one expert. But another expert and a patient contend that the evidence supports the use of these drugs, in a debate on the pages of The British Medical Journal.

New guidelines on life-prolonging treatments

The American Thoracic Society aimed has released new guidelines for crucial decision-making for the care of patients with advanced critical illness while preventing conflicts between medical staff and family caregivers.

The pseudoscience of beauty products.

beautyproducts.jpgThe beauty industry is massive, a huge cultural force in a tight, symbiotic relationship with celebrities and the celebrity-oriented media. So by its very nature, it creates massive problems for anyone seeking to get to the truth about the products it makes and promotes, writes Prof Timothy Caulfield of the School of Public Health at the University of Alberta, in The Atlantic.

Dr Google may trigger ‘cyberchondria'

Google.jpg Major search engines are providing irrelevant information that could lead to incorrect self-diagnosis, self-treatment and ultimately possible harm, research has found. Google reports that one in 20 of its 100bn searches a month was for health-related information. Some 35% of US adults go online to self-diagnose a medical condition.

Debate around 'excited delirium' diagnosis

Police, medical examiners and some doctors say 'excited delirium' is real and frightening, reports the Washington Post. Influenced by mental illness or the use of such stimulants, those in its grip often have extraordinary strength, are impervious to pain and act wildly or violently. Then, suddenly, some die. But others say it is merely a cover for the use of excessive force by law enforcement.

Münchausen by internet — how one woman fooled millions

Gibson.jpegAustralian blogger Belle Gibson has been exposed for fabricating a tragic cancer story that brought her fame and riches: various publishing contracts and large donations to a ‘charity’ which she plundered. But Gibson’s strange behaviour is not that unusual – faking disease in return for online fame is now a recognised medical condition.

Concerns over 'deprioritising' of medical research

Concerns are being raised  over new models of medical education in the US in which research plays a minimal role,  as being likely to create a two-tiered system of education, decrease the physician-scientist pipeline and diminish the application of scientific advances to patient care.

'You can't outrun a bad diet' – BMJ experts

Regular exercise is key to staving off serious disease, such as diabetes, heart disease, and dementia, write experts in an editorial in the British Medical Journal, but calorie laden diets now generate more ill health than physical inactivity, alcohol, and smoking combined.

ER doctor grieving

Grievingdoc2It’s grainy, it’s blurred. But a paramedic’s touching photograph of a Californian ER doctor doubled over, taking a moment to compose himself after losing a 19-year-old patient, has gone viral. ‘Hearing that a family member has died is such an awful and wrenching experience for the relative that it's easy to forget the emotional toll that must be taken by doctors sharing the news,’ wrote The Independent, London. Qatar Day wrote ‘It's easy to forget the incredible work doctors are doing every single day.’

‘White plasma’ — commercialising breast milk

breastmilpackages.jpgBreast milk, that most ancient and fundamental of nourishments, is becoming an industrial commodity, and one of the newest frontiers of the biotechnology industry — even as concerns abound over this fast-growing business, writes The New York Times.

Changing face of healthcare industry

StratBusNew entrants and established players are racing to create the next generation of medical products and services, writes Strategy+Business. Increasing numbers of consumers are willing to abandon traditional care venues for more affordable and convenient alternatives. Many would choose at-home or retail options for more than a dozen medical conditions or procedures such as self-diagnosing ailments with kits.

Lessons from CROI 2015

Gallant.jpgDr Joel Gallant immediate past chair of the HIV Medicine Association, has spoken about five important lessons learned at the CROI 2015 conference on the prevention of HIV and the future clinical implications of some of the major studies that were presented, reports Healio.

Official NHS calculator predicts your heart attack

HeartBritain’s NHS has launched a controversial calculator which predicts when you will have a heart attack or stroke - and compares a person’s ‘heart age’ with their biological age. But some critics raised concerns about the accuracy of a 'blunt tool' which tells every Briton they will have a heart attack or stroke one day, when many will not, and raised fears that the tool could be used to push millions more people into taking medication.

30-day mortality: The pressure of statistics

mortalityThere is growing criticism of 30-day mortality as a measure of surgical success, writes The New York Times. 'That seemingly innocuous metric may actually undermine appropriate care, especially for older adult.'

'Lie back and think of your career' – Ozz surgeon

McMullinA senior surgeon in Australia has triggered controversy after telling junior female doctors to go along with sexual abuse at work for the sake of their careers.

Anti-abortionIst confused about female anatomy

Vito BarbieriAn United States politician asked a testifying physician testifying before a House State Affairs Committee whether a woman could have a remote gynaecological exam by swallowing a tiny camera. The doctor explained that items swallowed do not end up in the vagina.

Cause of suffering decisive in euthanasia

EuthanasiaMore than 85% of Dutch doctors would help a patient die, while 60% said they had done so. Around 1 in 3 said they would consider it if a patient were suffering from early dementia or mental illness. This is according to a VU University Amsterdam study that surveyed almost 1,500 doctors.

Judge gives permission to withhold treatment

Doctors believe that a terminally-ill British teenager who has a brain tumour will die within weeks after a judge gave them permission to withhold treatment. The 18-year-old man’s parents had wanted chemotherapy to continue.

The issue of 'googling' patients

DocgoogleThe practice of ‘googling’ others may be ubiquitous in most fields, but it is an unresolved dilemma for professional medical bodies, write the authors of a study in the Journal of General Internal Medicine.

Judge: 'Therapeutic sterilisation … not eugenics'

Sterilisation A British mother-of-six with learning disabilities can be sterilised, a judge has ruled. Health authority and social services bosses had asked him to authorise forced entry into the woman’s home, the use of 'necessary restraint' and sterilisation, at a hearing in the Court of Protection – where issues relating to sick and vulnerable people are examined.

SA’s Health minister and opposition MP slug it out over forensic failures

motsoalediThe operation of the national Health Department’s Forensic Chemistry Laboratories (FCL) has developed into a fiery exchange of public statements between Health Minister Dr Aaron Motsoaledi and the Democratic Alliance (DA) MP Wilmot James after the opposition MP was denied access to the Durban FCL.

Why outlandish HIV/Aids beliefs persist

Few diseases have had a greater education effort poured into them than HIV/Aids. So why, writes Professor David Dickinson, a sociologist at Wits University,  after almost 30 years of public health messages do alternative, non-scientific explanations of Aids continue to circulate?

Experimental drugs causing concern

A new wave of experimental cancer drugs that directly recruit the immune system's powerful T cells are proving to be immensely effective weapons against tumours. But top oncology researchers are concerned, citing dangers seen repeatedly in clinical trials.

Cape Town wants clarity on e-cigarettes

Smartphone Cape Town says it will escalate its efforts for legislative clarity on the wide range of alternative smoking devices and habits that have become commonplace in SA, including the use of electronic cigarettes (e-cigarettes), reports Business Day. Meanwhile, The New York Times reports that initial public enthusiasm for e-cigarettes is waning among health and quality concerns.

UK debates ‘three-parent’ IVF regulation

Controversial British regulations effectively legalising so-called ‘three-parent’ IVF babies are expected to be debated and voted on by MPs before the general election, and could even be passed within weeks, despite safety concerns.

The Tests…

1. The 'alcohol abuser' test… Answering yes to just two questions – Do you regularly have more than six drinks in one sitting? Do you...

New ‘right to end life’ debate rages in Britain

Terminally ill patients should be provided with the professional equivalent of midwives to help ease the pain and suffering and if necessary shorten the...

Controversial ‘certificate of need’ legislation on hold

The South African national Department of Health has postponed its controversial plans to regulate where doctors work, saying it needs more time to craft...

Ban on hand-shaking

Sweaty palms, vice-like grips or the insufferable limp hand may be the least of your hand-shaking worries, reports BBC News. Scientists at Aberystwyth University...

More and more Americans consuming cannabis

More Americans are consuming cannabis as their perception of the health risks declines, the UN Office on Drugs and Crime (Undoc) said, suggesting liberalisation...